Acados error status 2 on python interface

CanO · January 8, 2020, 3:02pm

Hello,

I have been getting a lot of the following message “acados returned status 2. Exiting”. This usually happens when tuning the weights and the problem hyper parameters, so it feels like it is somewhat tied to the problem feasibility. Nevertheless, understanding what concretely this status entails would help me a great deal.

Are there any public materials where the statuses are explained?

Cheers,

Can

FreyJo · January 8, 2020, 11:00pm

Hi Can,

the acados return values are:
0 – success
1 – failure
2 – maximum number of iterations reached
3 – minimum step size in QP solver reached
4 – qp solver failed

It is defined in this file:

github.com

acados/acados/blob/dbc1c306ddaeefcb755d2afb289a25495446e008/acados/utils/types.h#L66




typedef int (*casadi_function_t)(const double** arg, double** res, int* iw, double* w, void* mem);






// enum of return values
enum return_values
{
    ACADOS_SUCCESS,
    ACADOS_FAILURE,
    ACADOS_MAXITER,
    ACADOS_MINSTEP,
    ACADOS_QP_FAILURE,
    ACADOS_READY,
};






// opts values ( please keep in alphabetical order ! )
// TODO outdated, proably remove !!!!!!!!!
enum acados_opts

Since you got 2, I would first consider increasing the number of iterations.

Cheers,
Jonathan

CanO · January 9, 2020, 1:53pm

Hey Jonathan,

Thanks so much for the reply, this clears a lot. But I have a question regarding the maximum iterations. Is it still a relevant variable when doing the real time iteration with SQP? Because I thought that there is a fixed iteration size of 1 in RTI.

Another question is for the error outputs of the QP solvers. I have looked for a similar enum in the files but have failed to locate one. Can you also help me with “QP solver returned error status 3” similarly?

Thanks and Cheers,

Can

FreyJo · January 9, 2020, 2:48pm

Hey Can,

you are welcome!

Indeed SQP_RTI should never return status 2, since always does 1 SQP Iteration.

The QP error status is different for each QP solver, it is defined in the QP solver Code itself which is located in /external/*.
Which one are you using?

Cheers,
Jonathan

CanO · January 9, 2020, 2:55pm

Hey Jonathan,

I am currently using the full condensing version of qpOASES, but perhaps out of pure coincidence, I get the same error also when using partial condensing HPIPM, so I assumed that there was unified error for all the QP solvers.

Cheers,

Can

FreyJo · January 9, 2020, 4:49pm

Hi Can,

in this case you can try to initialize the problem better.
If multiple QP solvers fail, it might be that your problem is infeasible or numerically ill-conditioned.
One can not really tell without having a closer look.

Since you wrote:

I want to mention that choosing weights of very different magnitude can easiliy lead to ill-conditioning.

Cheers!

adkr · November 24, 2024, 8:26am

Afaik, the value representation of enums is allowed to be implementation-specific. Unless you define ACADOS_SUCCESS = 0, those numbers could mean anything.